Cream Cheese Spread in Cheesecake? Yes, It Works!

Cheese Spread Twist: Perfect Cheesecake Hack!

You can use cream cheese spread instead of regular cream cheese for cheesecake, but it may alter the consistency. Adjustments like reducing sugar and adding stabilizers like gelatin might be needed due to the spread’s softer texture and added ingredients.

For Cheesecake, Can I Use Cream Cheese Spread? 

If you don’t have any cream cheese to hand, then you may be tempted to use cream cheese spread instead for cheesecake. 

They look and taste similar, so what could go wrong?

To be fair, it is possible to use a cream cheese spread, but you would need to prepare the recipe differently.

And the cheesecake may not turn out as expected.

First of all, there are a couple of reasons why cream cheese spread is easier to spread if that makes sense! 

It is softer than ordinary cream cheese, and that is due to additives, such as whey protein.

The whey protein changes the texture.

Plus, during the cheesemaking process, more air is added to the cream cheese spread, known as aeration, again making it softer and easier to use.

So, you need to change the consistency of the cheese spread before using it for cheesecake.

First of all, whip the spread so it’s very smooth.

Otherwise, it will stick and form clumps with the other ingredients.

Next, add plain yogurt to the whipped spread, but make sure you drain it first.

Once combined, add the rest of the ingredients. 

There is one further question as regards using cream cheese spreads for cheesecake – will it be set?

The lighter, softer texture of the spread doesn’t set easily, and you may need to add a small amount of gelatin to the recipe to encourage the process.

Do You Need Cheese for Cheesecake?

It is possible to make cheesecake without any cheese at all. 

This sounds a bit unlikely, as clearly, this delicious dessert is called cheesecake for a reason and is typically made with cream cheese.

But surprisingly, you can substitute the cream cheese for sour cream.

When you think about it, sour cream is made similarly to cheese; it is fermented, and of course, it’s still a dairy product.

You might expect the cheesecake to have a sour taste to it, but when the other ingredients are added, especially the sugar, it’s much the same.

Maybe a little creamier, slightly less sweet, and not as heavy as some regular cheesecakes can be.

Using sour cream for the cheesecake filling goes well with citrus flavors such as lemon.

A photograph of two slices of cheesecake

Cream Cheese Showdown: Block vs. Spread in Cheesecake

When diving into the world of cheesecakes, a key question often arises: what’s the difference between cream cheese and cream cheese spread, and how does this affect our beloved dessert?

The distinction lies in the texture and ingredient composition.

A cream cheese block, the traditional choice for cheesecake, boasts a dense and rich texture.

Its firmness is due to a higher fat content and less moisture, making it the ideal candidate for that classic, sturdy cheesecake we all know and love.

On the other hand, cream cheese spread, often found in tubs, is whipped and contains added stabilizers and moisture.

This makes it softer and more spreadable, perfect for a quick bagel topping but a bit of a wildcard in cheesecakes.

When you use cream cheese spread in cheesecake, you’re signing up for a dessert that’s potentially lighter and creamier, but with the risk of it not setting as firmly as its block counterpart.

The battle of cream cheese block vs spread in cheesecakes is not just about texture; it’s also about the authenticity of flavor.

Is cream cheese in cheesecake non-negotiable?

For purists, perhaps.

But for the adventurous baker, cream cheese spread offers a world of creamy possibilities, albeit with a few adjustments to the recipe.

Ultimately, the choice boils down to personal preference and the desired outcome of your cheesecake masterpiece.

Whether you choose the block or the spread, you’re embarking on a delicious journey of creamy, cheesy goodness!

What Can I Substitute for Cream Cheese?

My Final Thoughts

  • Cream cheese spread can be used for cheesecake, but it’s not the ideal choice due to additives like whey protein and aeration during manufacturing, resulting in a softer texture.
  • To improve consistency, mix drained yogurt with whipped cream cheese spread before combining it with other cheesecake ingredients.
  • There’s a risk that cheesecakes made with cream cheese spread won’t set properly, possibly requiring the addition of gelatin to the recipe.
  • The difference in texture and potential clumping of the spread when mixed with other ingredients are key considerations when substituting for regular cream cheese.
  • For a completely different approach, sour cream can be used as a unique and effective substitute for cream cheese in cheesecakes, particularly complementing citrus flavors.

Cream cheese spread can be used for cheesecakes but needs an additional ingredient for the correct texture.

Drained yogurt will change the cheese spread to the right consistency.

The cream cheese spread also needs to be whipped first; otherwise, it clumps together with other ingredients. 

If the cheesecake doesn’t set, then gelatin can be added to the recipe.

And if you don’t have any suitable cheese products, you can use sour cream for your cheesecake.

So, there is always an option if cheesecake is on the menu!  

If you are wondering about other substitutions for your favorite dessert, check out my article on using cottage cheese in cheesecake.

Ready to experiment with your cheesecake recipe?

Will you stick with traditional cream cheese or try the unique twist of using cream cheese spread?

How do you think this flexibility in ingredients reflects broader trends in cooking?

Let us know in the comments below!

🍰 Cheesecake Recipe Variations 🍓

IngredientAdjustment with Cream Cheese Spread
Cream CheeseUse an equivalent amount of cream cheese spread
SugarReduce slightly, as spreads may contain added sweeteners
Fat (e.g., Butter)Adjust based on the fat content of the spread
Stabilizers (e.g., Gelatin)May need to add for firmer texture
Brought to You by

FAQs: Using Cream Cheese Spread in Cheesecake

Q: Can I directly substitute cream cheese spread for regular cream cheese in cheesecake recipes?
A: Yes, but be aware that cream cheese spread has a softer consistency and different additives, which might affect the texture of your cheesecake.

Q: Will the taste of my cheesecake change if I use cream cheese spread?
A: The taste may be slightly different due to the additives in the cream cheese spread. However, it will still have a similar cream cheese flavor.

Q: Do I need to make any adjustments to my recipe when using a cream cheese spread?
A: You might need to adjust the amount of sugar or fat, and consider adding a stabilizing agent like gelatin to ensure proper setting.

Q: Is it possible to achieve the same texture as traditional cheesecake with cream cheese spread?
A: The texture might be softer and less dense. For a firmer texture, consider blending drained yogurt or sour cream with the cream cheese spread.

Q: Are there any specific brands of cream cheese spread recommended for cheesecake?
A: No specific brand is recommended, but opt for full-fat versions for a richer taste and better texture.

Q: Can I use a flavored cream cheese spread for a different twist on my cheesecake?
A: Absolutely! Flavored cream cheese spreads can add unique tastes to your cheesecake, just be mindful of the additional sugar and flavorings.

Q: If my cheesecake doesn’t set properly, what can I do?
A: To rescue a cheesecake that hasn’t set, chilling it for longer may help. If it remains too soft, serving it as a creamy dessert bowl with toppings can be a delightful alternative.

A photograph of two cheesecake slices

Leave a Comment